Treating the Whole Body…. Not JUST Treating Symptoms

“The doctor of the future will give no medicine, but will instruct his patient in the care of the human frame, in diet, and in the cause and prevention of disease.” – Thomas A. Edison

Let’s start with an excerpt from the services page on my website**:

• OMM is a treatment commonly used for patients who have strained their back either playing sports or at work, or have been involved in a “whiplash” injury from an accident. Also, many people who have sedentary jobs, or sit for a long time at a desk develop “knots” in the shoulder blade region. By performing OMM, a procedure designed to mobilize the restricted motion of the joint, a DO helps relieve symptoms which then aid in tapping into your body’s self-healing capabilities.

Manual medicine is one component of total health care and is most effective in the long term when combined with diet, exercise, and lifestyle modification. As well, OMM can work alongside conventional approaches to help patients with a wide variety of conditions. Consider a concept forwarded by Edward Stiles, DO (http://omtsos.com/index.php?page=philosophy) that further describes the goal of manual medicine practitioners with the following equation:

 HOST + DISEASE = ILLNESS

Using the equation above, consider a patient with asthma: the patient is the Host component and asthma represents the Disease component of this equation. To treat the host, manual medicine is directed at the patient’s mechanical restriction which commonly occurs in the thoracic spine and rib cage region (http://www.spine-health.com/conditions/spine-anatomy/thoracic-spine-anatomy-and-upper-back-pain).  The primary goal is to restore motion to the ribcage, diaphragm, and thorax, and in doing so, restore normal ventilation of the lungs.

Furthermore, to treat the disease (asthma has two components: inflammation or mucus build-up in the airways and broncho-constriction or narrowing of the airways), inhaled steroids to decrease inflammation in the lungs and other medicines called broncho-dilators to expand the lungs are used to treat the patient successfully. From a 2010 article in OMPC, Osteopathic Medicine and Primary Care (http://www.om-pc.com/content/4/1/2 Noll et al.), hospital patients with pneumonia were treated in a similar fashion described above (using OMM and conventional therapy –  ie; antibiotics – versus just conventional therapy). Patients treated with the combined approach of OMM and conventional treatment were discharged from the hospital sooner than those just treated with the conventional treatment of medications without OMM.

So, what are the implications of this model for healthcare? Approaching the patient with this integrative method takes us away from just treating symptoms, and when taking into consideration that the HOST is connected to the ILLNESS equation (and not just the DISEASE – ie; symptoms), this optimizes the patient’s own healing capabilities.

** http://www.pursuitsports.us/services/

For more information, please visit: www.pursuitsports.us

Physical Therapy vs Surgery for Meniscal Tears

 “I don’t deserve this award, but I have arthritis and I don’t deserve that either.” 
-Jack Benny

Before I dive into the findings of a recent New England Journal of Medicine study and how this connects to what is called “conservative treatment” (ie; non-surgical), here is a brief description of the medical terminology needed to understand the results and how this fits into your own treatment choices.

The two medical terms involved with this study are menisci and arthritis.

• Menisci are C-shaped cartilage structures within the knee joint which act like shock absorbers or cushions between the thigh bone (femur) and the shin bone (tibia). The menisci also provide stability with various motions of the knee including pivoting, twisting and squatting. Surgery for meniscal tears is the most commonly performed orthopedic surgery.
• Meniscectomy is surgically removing the torn part of the meniscus which takes out the “pain generator” and prevents torn pieces from breaking off and causing further injury
• Arthritis is a narrowing of the joint space associated with degeneration of the cartilage and bony structures of a joint.

Now to the findings of the study published in the New England Journal of Medicine, (NEJM, March 19, 2013 – http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa1301408 ). This study indicated that physical therapy vs surgery is no different in efficacy for the treatment of meniscal tears among patients with mild to moderate arthritis. In this well designed study, patients with an average age of 56 were randomly assigned to either the conservative treatment group consisting of physical therapy or the surgical group which was treated with a partial meniscectomy. Further results showed that 30% of the patients in the conservative treatment group receiving physical therapy “crossed over” to get surgical treatment within 6 months. At 6 months and 12 months, the conservative treatment group compared to the surgery group indicated no difference on the WOMAC pain and function scales (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WOMAC ).

Furthermore, as cited in my December 2012 blog article: (https://pursuitsports.wordpress.com/2012/12/14/huh-an-introduction-to-making-sense-of-what-your-doctor-is-trying-and-failing-to-tell-you/ ), shoulder MRI’s in the general population of asymptomatic patients show a high proportion of rotator cuff tears. Similarly,  35% of patients older than 50 will have meniscal tears seen on an MRI, and 67% of them will be asymptomatic (this means that patients do not report any painful symptoms). So, it is worth mentioning again the importance of the physical examination to determine if the meniscus truly is the origin of the pain and then correlating these findings with the MRI before considering aggressive or surgical procedures.

So, what does this mean for patients? General recommendations can emphasize non-surgical treatments for meniscal tears first, as long as they do not have mechanical symptoms (ie; locking, catching or giving way). If the patient shows no improvement after non-surgical treatments or has mechanical symptoms, then considering surgical management would be the next step.

Finally, what about regenerative injections to optimize conservative treatments? There is mounting medical evidence that regenerative injections can be helpful in patients with knee arthritis, so why not engage in this non-surgical treatment for meniscal tears? At present, there are no studies in this specific population of patients who have meniscal tears without arthritis, however, I generally tell patients who want to avoid surgery that we can try non-surgical treatments as long as mechanical symptoms (knee joint locking or catching) are not present. In this New England Journal of Medicine article, the study participants will be followed into the future in order to answer the question as to weather surgery on the meniscus leads to a higher risk of arthritis. If this turns out to be so, then it would be another argument to treat these injuries conservatively with physical therapy and regenerative injections.

For more information, please visit: www.pursuitsports.us
 

 

Commitment to Recovery is a Two-Way Street

“I heard a definition once: Happiness is health and a short memory! I wish I’d invented it, because it is very true.”   – Katherine Hepburn

When I was working as an intern, I was at an underserved community health clinic on the Southside of Chicago where there is a high prevalence of obesity, high blood pressure and diabetes. I was taught to treat the symptoms of these conditions via drugs with only cursory attention given to advising patients on lifestyle modifications.  After watching this approach only slow down or “manage” the conditions as patients were oftentimes only passively involved in their care, I found myself wanting some structure to get to the “root cause” as a doctor in training.

Finally, I began to have patients journal their dietary intake and what they ate everyday for two weeks, as well as document their activities such as walking or other forms of exercise. Then I would invite them back for an office visit and ask them to take an honest assessment of what they ate and what they could do without. Patients were amazed when they reviewed their diets and often commented on certain habits and “automatic eating” types of behaviors relating to stress or “self-medicating”. For some of the patients, the awareness gained from creating a journal propelled them into “I can do without that second snickers bar” or “I can take the stairs instead of the elevator”. They embarked on successful weight loss programs with this simple strategy by decreasing dietary intake and increasing physical activity. Several patients succeeded with this approach, and one in particular that I recall (Mary G.) lost over 60 pounds and kept it off the remainder of my residency training!

So, why does this matter?

We know that when patients are more engaged in their care, it leads to better outcomes. That’s a fact. On average, patients with high blood pressure and diabetes when stable, go to their doctor 4 times a year for a 15 minute appointment – so that is 1 hour of time with their doctor per year. Really, it’s what patients can do on a daily basis with their own health that can make a positive impact on their health… and of course, working in collaboration with health care providers.

In musculoskeletal medicine and for conditions such as chronic neck and back pain, we see that this engagement of the patient via therapeutic exercise along with spinal manipulation works. As reported in a review on spinal pain in The Spine Journal, 2008, a patient’s commitment to recovery decreases pain and increases function. I never get tired of repeating certain pieces of advice or “truths” in my experience: get informed, get involved with the entire program to recovery, make sure a sincere commitment has been made to move forward. Make sure your friends and family understand what your condition is and what recovery looks like. Get support. Do the exercises.

Eat ice cream (unless you are lactose intolerant – then have some dark chocolate!). That last suggestion is for unplugging and lightening up, too. Obesity is often a disease of the mind as well, so focus on reversing inertia tendencies in your lives and ask yourselves what you could do without? Get a journal and write it all down – two weeks worth of food and drink. Write down some goals you have, too. You might be surprised at what the results will tell you. Time to get going. Let you and your doctor work together for a full recovery. It’s a two-way street, right? You can do this!

For more information, please visit: www.pursuitsports.us